Prior
to the second debate, Jay H. Ell had already written Romney off as toast,
notwithstanding the fact that the media had maintained that Obama was in
"deep trouble" as a result of one sub par debate performance. The
media now had a horse race so the political parties and PACS doubled up on
media advertising, which is very very costly at this stage of the campaign. So
it is fair to say that there is a media self interest to keep this as a horse
race.
"MAKE
OR BREAK FOR OBAMA"
The
second debate was make or break for Obama or so they said. All this when it was
all but impossible for Romney to win. The Huffington Post electoral map had
Obama with a winning 271 electoral votes, either definite or strongly leaning to Obama, even after his "calamitous" debate performance. This number of
electoral delegates excluded the "toss up" states, Nevada, Colorado,
Virginia, Florida, New Hampshire and North Carolina. Put another way even if
Romney won all the latter he would still lose.
The
newly more conservative CNN had a lead story on their website, "Can Obama stop
a Romney win?" However their electoral map similarly rated Romney
chanceless. They gave Obama 237 electoral votes adding Iowa, Wisconsin and Ohio
as "toss up" states. This was very charitable indeed as those 34
electoral votes are sown up by Obama but CNN's assessment certainly adds to the
interest and certainly just might just increase their advertising revenue.
Ohio has been hyped to kingdom come. Ohio that has been in Obama's column for months. His ground game is eons ahead of Romneys with more than double the field offices. The Republican State's legislature last ditch attempt to limit Democratic voting failed court challenges. So Romney would have to be the first Republican to win the Presidency without Ohio.
So as Shakespeare might have said if he had had a tweet account, this is all"Much Ado About Nothing". So like everything else around here elections have become a spectator sport.
So as Shakespeare might have said if he had had a tweet account, this is all"Much Ado About Nothing". So like everything else around here elections have become a spectator sport.
"MODERATE MITT" AND THE FIRST DEBATE
It
was totally forgotten that it was a new "etch a sketch" Romney that
"won" the first debate. As Bill Clinton said that "Moderate
Mitt" had not been around for a long time. Romney abandoned his Tea Party
positions and went back to his moderate Massachusetts positions. The only
question Clinton could not answer was why Obama let Romney go unchallenged in
that first debate. Neither could Jay H Ell understand the Obama tactics. (Blog: Obama AND Romney No Show at the Debate).
Romney
had abandoned his position that "it was fair" that he paid less tax
than middle class citizens that earned $50,000 and all in all he was
unrecognizable as the Romney that had won the Republican nomination. He could not explain how the math worked for his tax plan. The time had come for all good conservatives to rally round the party!
POLLS
AND POLLS
Opinion
polls that showed Obama ahead on every conceivable parameter such as
likeability and to fix the economy for example, inexplicably found Romney to be
equal or even ahead in the popular vote, following the debate. Now opinion polls in the
USA can unashamedly have bias. There are Republican pollsters and Democratic
pollsters. There are samples that contain more voters of one party or another.
There are questions that are more likely to get a partisan response than
another. So you have to be selective as to which polls you take notice of.
BIDEN
VERSUS RYAN
Biden
massacred Ryan. It was not only a victory for Biden but it was an answer to the
"malarkey" of Romney on taxes and the like. Biden
laid the ground for Obama to come back on all the issues that he ostensibly
"gave" to Romney in the first debate. Biden was authoritative, knowledgeable and fiesty firing up the base allowing Obama to gain the ascendency in the media battle. The CBS network poll made Biden a winner by 20 points and the other immediate "scientific" poll, CNN's gave it to Ryan by 4 points!
THE
SECOND TOWN HALL DEBATE
So the stage was set for a"new" Obama or a return of the "old" Obama or whatever. Obama was aggressive, positive and not giving an
inch. From taxes to immigration to women's rights to job creation to foreign
policy, Obama took Romney to the cleaners.
Romney
was backtracking on everything from birth control availability to everything
else.
Romney
was not really happy with the way the debate went. We saw a side of him that was hidden in the first debate. He was testy, irritable and in your face. He is not to used to not getting things his own way apparently.
There is no doubt that there will be criticism of the moderator Candy Crowley who had the audacity to fact check Romney on what Obama said immediately after the Libyan Embassy Attack. This attack is Romney's big foreign policy issue. He forgets that he got it all wrong in the beginning, Biden pointed out to Ryan that it was his budget cuts that decreased the security money to the embassies in the first place and that Hillary Clinton took full responsibility for the whole incident the day before.
There is no doubt that there will be criticism of the moderator Candy Crowley who had the audacity to fact check Romney on what Obama said immediately after the Libyan Embassy Attack. This attack is Romney's big foreign policy issue. He forgets that he got it all wrong in the beginning, Biden pointed out to Ryan that it was his budget cuts that decreased the security money to the embassies in the first place and that Hillary Clinton took full responsibility for the whole incident the day before.
The immediate CBS and even the CNN poll gave Obama a clear victory. This with the fact that Obama
was winning anyway should allow us to move on and look on to the other
congressional races and the future of America generally. However, this did
not stop the CNN poll from interpreting some aspects of the debate in favor of Romney
even though CNN conceded that their responders were far more Republican than
usual. (Maybe between this disconnect and the massive Biden - Ryan disconnect CNN should check the methodology of the "scientific" pollsters).
So
the media will continue to stoke this up as a horse race. Obama has got his mojo back and there is one more debate. But remember
regardless of the hype Romney has to win all those states to win. His
performance in the second debate did not improve his chances. Things can only
get worse for him. On the newsfront is the fact that a company called Sensata in Freeport Illinois is a company that Bain is
moving to China with a loss of a 170 jobs.
BAIN
AND JOB CREATION IN USA
The
employees of the Sensata Company are more than aware of their political clout
in their life or death issue. They initially appealed to Romney to help them
and this was ignored. Now they are going viral. By the end of the week they are
going to be the centerpiece of MSNBC'S Ed Schultz show.
The
whole issue of Bain is indicative of the business model that Romney represents
that is only interested in profit and is outsourcing a viable
company to China and losing a 170 American jobs. And Romney, who still owns 51% of Bain,
is arguing that his business experience can save America by creating jobs.
One just wonders how all this will play in Ohio and how the media will keep the pot boiling for yet another 3 weeks.
I'm not sure that Jay.H.Ell and I are watching the same election. Last night, the Gallup rolling poll of likely voters had Romney in front 51 to 45 whereas before the first debate Obama was leading by 5 points. That first Obama performance did a hell of a lot of damage. He was incomparably better second time round but we will need to wait a few days to see if this is reflected in the polls. Jay.H.Ell believes that Obama has a lock on Ohio and Iowa. If he's right it will almost certainly mean a Democratic victory. The VP debate was important because it re-energised the base and boy did it it need it after the presidential no show in Denver.But whether Biden's fixed "here's Johnny" grin and bullying of Paul Ryan will have swung the Independents is open to doubt. Likewise the Town Hall debate. Obama won it by common consent but it was a points win as opposed to the knockout in Denver.
ReplyDeleteSo Obama remains favourite but to imply,as Jay.H.Ell does, that he is effectively home and hosed, is to my mind ridiculous.
A very valid viewpoint. Only time is going to tell. One out of 8 jobs in Ohio depend on the auto industry that Obama bailed out, Ohio is one of the few states that has a strong Union presence.
ReplyDeleteObama has very stong ties to Iowa which is the basis of his Presidency. He spent months there so as to win the Democratic Primary and make him a serious challenger to Hillary Clinton. Obama still has a very strong ground game in Iowa. Obama has supported steadfastly 10% ethanol, made from corn in Petroleum.The latter process is not part of Romney's drill baby drill caucus.
Romney is not very popular in Iowa he came second to Santorum in the Primary with 25% of the Republican vote. His ground game is almost ziltch
So the Huffington post assessment is not baseless. The margin that Obama has been consistently ahead in these two states has a lot of meat behind it.